Ng Shiu appeared for Tasman, raising the interest of Samoan coach Sir Gordon Tietjens.
But here's where things get murky.
On the second day's play in Rotorua, Tietjens was seen, in the grandstand, talking to Ng Shiu.
Tietjens says that the 22-year-old, Napier-born Ng Shiu, while not a standout, would have been good value for his young Samoan side.